BY STAT PULSE MEDIA
Every NFL season, quarterbacks are judged by the numbers they produce. Passing yards, touchdowns, interceptions, and completion percentage dominate television broadcasts and social media discussions.
But as the 2026 season begins, one question deserves more attention: are the quarterbacks with the most impressive traditional statistics actually playing the best football?
The answer is more complicated than it might appear.
A quarterback can throw for 350 yards and still have a disappointing performance. Another can finish with fewer than 200 passing yards and play an essential role in a victory.
Understanding the difference requires looking beyond the box score.
Why Passing Yards Can Be Misleading
Passing yards measure the total distance gained on completed passes, including yards gained by receivers after catching the football.
This creates an important distinction.
Suppose Quarterback A throws a short five-yard pass to a receiver who breaks several tackles and runs another 65 yards for a touchdown.
The quarterback receives credit for a 70-yard touchdown pass, even though the football traveled only five yards through the air.
Now consider Quarterback B, who throws a perfectly placed 40-yard pass into tight coverage. His receiver catches the ball and is immediately tackled.
Quarterback B receives credit for 40 yards, despite arguably making the more difficult throw.
This is why passing yardage alone cannot accurately measure quarterback ability.
One alternative is average depth of target, commonly abbreviated as ADOT.
ADOT measures the average distance downfield a quarterback targets receivers, regardless of whether the passes are completed.
A quarterback with a high ADOT generally attempts deeper throws, while one with a low ADOT relies more heavily on short passes.
Neither approach is automatically better. Short passes can create efficient offenses, while deeper attempts can produce explosive plays.
The important question is whether the quarterback's approach consistently helps his team score.
Completion Percentage Versus Expected Completion Percentage
Completion percentage is one of football's most familiar statistics.
If a quarterback completes 24 of 30 passes, his completion percentage is 80%.
That sounds impressive, but it doesn't explain how difficult those passes were.
A quarterback throwing mostly short passes to wide-open receivers should generally complete a higher percentage of attempts than one throwing deep passes against tight coverage.
To account for these differences, analysts use Completion Percentage Over Expected, or CPOE.
CPOE compares a quarterback's actual completion percentage with the completion percentage predicted by a statistical model.
The model considers factors such as throw distance, receiver separation, and defensive pressure.
For example, imagine a quarterback completes 72% of his passes when the model expects 65%.
His CPOE would be +7 percentage points.
That means he completed passes at a rate seven percentage points higher than expected.
Another quarterback might complete 75% of his passes but have a CPOE of -2 percentage points because his attempts were considerably easier.
Although the second quarterback had the higher raw completion percentage, the first performed better relative to the difficulty of his throws.
The Importance of Expected Points Added
Expected Points Added, or EPA, provides another way to evaluate quarterback performance.
Rather than simply measuring yards, EPA evaluates how much each play changes a team's expected scoring outcome.
Consider two hypothetical passing plays.
On third-and-15, a quarterback completes a 12-yard pass. The offense gains substantial yardage but still faces fourth down.
On third-and-4, another quarterback completes a six-yard pass for a first down.
The second play may generate more positive EPA because it extends the drive and improves the team's scoring opportunities.
EPA also accounts for negative plays.
An interception can produce a major negative EPA value because the offense loses possession and gives its opponent a chance to score.
This makes EPA particularly useful when comparing quarterbacks who play in different offensive systems.
Why Touchdowns and Interceptions Need Context
Touchdown-to-interception ratio is another commonly discussed quarterback statistic.
A quarterback with 30 touchdowns and 10 interceptions has a 3-to-1 ratio.
However, interceptions aren't always entirely the quarterback's responsibility.
A receiver might drop a well-thrown pass that is then intercepted. Conversely, a defender might drop an easy interception, allowing a quarterback's mistake to go unrecorded.
Touchdowns can also be influenced by teammates.
A quarterback who repeatedly hands the ball to a running back near the goal line may finish with fewer passing touchdowns than one whose offense frequently calls passing plays in the same situations.
These examples show why individual statistics must be evaluated within the context of team strategy.
The Best Way to Evaluate a Quarterback
There is no perfect quarterback statistic.
Passing yards reveal production. Completion percentage measures accuracy at a basic level. CPOE evaluates accuracy relative to difficulty. EPA measures the impact of plays on expected scoring.
The strongest evaluations combine these measurements.
For example, a quarterback who ranks highly in EPA per play, maintains a positive CPOE, and limits turnovers is probably helping his offense in several different ways.
But even those statistics should be considered alongside offensive line performance, receiver quality, and opponent strength.
A quarterback facing constant pressure may have fewer opportunities to succeed than one operating behind an elite offensive line.
What This Means for the 2026 Season
As the NFL season progresses, quarterback rankings will become a major topic.
Some players will produce impressive passing totals because their teams frequently throw the football. Others may post smaller numbers because their offenses rely on strong running games.
The challenge is separating opportunity from actual performance.
A quarterback's value isn't determined solely by how many yards he gains. It is determined by how effectively he creates scoring opportunities, avoids costly mistakes, and helps his team win.