MLB

MLB

Which MLB Statistics Best Predict Second-Half Breakouts?

Which MLB Statistics Best Predict Second-Half Breakouts?

Expected production, contact quality, plate discipline, batted-ball velocity, and playing time can reveal which struggling hitters are positioned for a second-half surge.

Expected production, contact quality, plate discipline, batted-ball velocity, and playing time can reveal which struggling hitters are positioned for a second-half surge.

BY STAT PULSE MEDIA

Every MLB season produces players who seem to become completely different hitters after the All-Star break. A player hitting .230 in June can suddenly become one of the most productive hitters in baseball by August. These performances are often described as “getting hot,” but many second-half breakouts are not as random as they appear.

Traditional statistics such as batting average, home runs and RBI tell us what has already happened. They do not always tell us how well a player has actually been hitting the baseball. To find potential breakout candidates, it can be more useful to look underneath those results.

Expected statistics, contact quality, plate discipline, batted-ball velocity and playing time can reveal hitters whose underlying performance is better than their traditional numbers suggest.

Expected Production: Looking Beyond Batting Average

One of the best places to start is Statcast’s expected statistics.

Expected batting average (xBA), expected slugging percentage (xSLG) and expected weighted on-base average (xwOBA) estimate what a hitter’s results should look like based largely on the quality of his contact. Statcast evaluates factors such as exit velocity and launch angle and compares a batted ball with similar balls hit throughout MLB history.

That distinction matters.

Imagine two players both hitting .240. Player A has a .245 expected batting average, while Player B has a .280 xBA. Their traditional statistics look almost identical, but the underlying data tells a different story.

Player A is performing roughly as expected. Player B may have been hitting the ball much better than his results indicate.

The same concept becomes even more useful with slugging.

Suppose a hitter has a .390 slugging percentage but a .470 xSLG. A gap that large suggests his contact has had the characteristics of a much more productive hitter. Some hard-hit balls may have gone directly at defenders, died near the warning track or simply produced worse results than similar batted balls normally produce.

That does not guarantee his luck will change. But it gives us a reason to believe his first-half numbers may be underselling his performance.

MLB describes xwOBA as particularly useful because it combines contact quality with strikeouts, walks and hit-by-pitches to provide a broader picture of offensive production.

For breakout hunting, a large positive difference between xwOBA and actual wOBA can therefore be an important signal.

Contact Quality: Is the Hitter Actually Crushing the Ball?

Expected statistics tell us what should have happened. Contact-quality statistics help explain why.

Exit velocity measures how fast the baseball leaves the bat. Hard-hit rate measures how frequently a hitter produces batted balls at 95 mph or harder.

These statistics help separate weak contact from legitimately dangerous contact.

A hitter with a low batting average and poor contact quality probably does not have an obvious statistical reason to expect a major turnaround. A hitter with mediocre results but consistently high-quality contact is far more interesting.

Barrel rate can provide an even stronger signal.

A barrel is essentially a batted ball combining the exit velocity and launch angle most likely to produce extra-base hits and home runs. A player consistently barreling baseballs has demonstrated the ability to create the type of contact that drives offensive production.

This is why evaluating only home runs can be misleading.

One hitter might have 15 first-half home runs despite mediocre underlying contact, while another has 10 despite producing more barrels and harder contact. The first hitter has the better traditional stat line, but the second might have the better profile going forward.

The goal is not to predict exactly how many home runs someone will hit. It is to determine whether the process underneath his results looks sustainable.

Plate Discipline: Can the Improvement Last?

A player can crush the baseball, but that ability becomes less valuable if he cannot consistently make contact or forces himself to swing at bad pitches.

That makes plate discipline another major piece of breakout analysis.

One particularly useful statistic is chase rate, also called O-Swing%. It measures how frequently a hitter swings at pitches outside the strike zone. FanGraphs defines O-Swing% as swings at pitches outside the zone divided by the total pitches a hitter sees outside the zone.

Lowering chase rate can produce a chain reaction.

Fewer swings at bad pitches can mean fewer whiffs. Fewer whiffs can mean fewer strikeouts. More favorable counts can create more opportunities to attack hittable pitches.

And unlike some traditional statistics, plate-discipline numbers can become informative relatively quickly because hitters see several pitches during every plate appearance. FanGraphs has noted that metrics such as chase rate can provide useful information earlier than statistics such as OPS.

There is evidence that these tendencies can also carry from one half of a season to the next. One FanGraphs analysis using hitters from 2015 through 2019 found a first-half-to-second-half correlation of .827 for O-Swing%, .833 for zone swing rate and .812 for outside-zone contact rate. For comparison, strikeout rate had a .794 correlation and walk rate a .713 correlation in the same analysis.

That doesn't mean every plate-discipline improvement is permanent. In fact, some apparent improvements regress toward a player's career norms.

The strongest breakout candidates are therefore players showing improvement across several areas rather than one statistic alone.

Velocity: Is Something Physically Different?

Another clue can be found in batted-ball velocity.

Instead of simply asking whether a player's average exit velocity is high, look at whether it is changing.

Consider a hitter whose average exit velocity progresses like this:

April: 88.0 mph May: 89.1 mph June: 91.0 mph July: 92.2 mph

That trend can be more informative than the season average.

Increasing velocity could reflect better timing, improved mechanics, recovery from an injury or simply more consistent hard contact. Whatever the reason, a player beginning to hit the ball significantly harder deserves attention.

But velocity should not be viewed alone. A hitter who adds exit velocity while maintaining good contact rates is considerably more interesting than one who simply swings harder and dramatically increases his strikeouts.

The best signal is improvement without a major sacrifice elsewhere.

Playing Time: The Statistic That Makes Everything Else Matter

There is one final variable that advanced models sometimes make too complicated: opportunity.

A player cannot have a major second-half breakout from the bench.

Changes in lineup position, injuries to teammates, trades and defensive improvements can suddenly create hundreds of additional plate appearances.

Consider two equally talented hitters. One receives 150 second-half plate appearances. The other receives 280.

Even if their rate statistics are identical, the second player has almost twice as many opportunities to accumulate hits, home runs, runs and RBI.

This makes projected playing time essential when identifying breakout candidates.

Building the Ideal Breakout Profile

There probably isn't one statistic capable of perfectly predicting the next second-half star. Baseball contains too much randomness for that.

Instead, the best approach is combining multiple indicators.

An ideal breakout candidate might have:

  • xwOBA significantly higher than actual wOBA

  • xSLG higher than actual slugging percentage

  • Strong or improving hard-hit and barrel rates

  • Increasing exit velocity

  • Declining chase and whiff rates

  • Stable or improving strikeout and walk rates

  • A clear path to everyday playing time

None guarantees a breakout.

But when several appear together, the case becomes much stronger.

That is ultimately the difference between identifying a player who is simply having a bad season and identifying one whose results have not caught up with his performance.

Baseball statistics are best at explaining what has already happened. The more interesting challenge is finding the numbers that tell us what might happen next.

And when searching for baseball's next second-half breakout, the scoreboard may actually be one of the last places we should look.

THE FINAL PULSE

THE FINAL PULSE

The strongest second-half breakout candidates do not rely on one lucky indicator. They combine a gap between expected and actual production with improving contact, disciplined swing decisions, rising batted-ball velocity, and a clear path to everyday playing time.

The strongest second-half breakout candidates do not rely on one lucky indicator. They combine a gap between expected and actual production with improving contact, disciplined swing decisions, rising batted-ball velocity, and a clear path to everyday playing time.

BY STAT PULSE MEDIA